Order Online

How to know when your pizza is ready for pickup!

1: The “Pick up now (Ready in XX)” time listed on our web ordering is not correct.

2: Enter your CELL PHONE number when ordering online.

3: We’ll text you when there is 10-15 minutes left on your order.

If you do not text we recommend calling your order in so you can be given a pick up time estimate.

“Crafted for Flavor”

Inside Duffy’s Tavern

60W Main Street, Madison Ohio

Dine In & Carry Out

Ph: 440-428-9937

Employment Opportunities

Kay Jack Pizza’s

Pre-Application Form:

We have the best customers! Here’s what a few are saying:

4.8 Star Google Rating
Ed M. “By far the best pizza around…”
Kitt L. “This is artisan pizza and you can taste it…”
Eric C. “Loaded with toppings and cooked perfectly…”
Chrissy P. “The pizza was delicious but unfortunately had to wait an hour…”

Why Kay Jack?

It’s our attention to detail that sets us apart. Quality ingredients and fresh products aren’t just marketing terms for us – they’re actually how we do business. We don’t sell frozen, reheated, and serve items.  Everything on our menu was created with attention to quality and crafted for flavor.

Unbleached, Unbromated Flour

Premium Vine-Ripened Tomatoes

Cheese free of Additives, Fillers or Preservatives

Kay Jack Pizza is located inside

Duffy’s Tavern

In May of 2021, Duffy’s Tavern invited a new Artisan Pizza Startup to operate out of their established kitchen. This was the birth of Kay Jack Pizza.

-Call your order in: 440-428-9937

-Hours: Monday – Saturday 4:00 – 8:00 pm

We’re best known for our Artisan Crust!

“Like a foundation to a home, if the crust isn’t right, the pizza isn’t right. I’ve spent years teaching myself how to make artisan breads and I keep learning every day.”

-Owner, Bill Hoon


Get in touch


Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program – Terms and Conditions

Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program – Terms and Conditions

Duration and Termination: The Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program is an ongoing program; however, Kay Jack Pizza reserves the right to cancel or modify the program at any time without prior notice. This includes the cancellation, reduction, or revocation of individual points, rewards, or gifts.

Eligibility: To join the Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program, individuals must be at least 18 years of age. The program is based on individual phone numbers, and rewards cannot be combined with other members’ balances. Reward balances are non-transferable.

Data Collection and Privacy: When signing up for the loyalty program, customers are required to provide their name, address, cell phone number, opt-in for SMS text messaging, email address, opt-in for email marketing, and date of birth. This data is protected by our point of sale loyalty program, and Kay Jack Pizza will not sell any customer data.

8th Pie Free: After purchasing 7 medium or large pizzas, customers earn a free medium or large cheese pizza. Additional charges apply for toppings, including stuffed crust.

Donate a Pie: Customers can donate a large cheese pizza to one of the selected groups for half the cost. Donated pizzas are redeemed with a Free Large Cheese Pizza Coupon provided by Kay Jack Pizza, and additional charges for toppings will apply, including stuffed crust.

Donation Limits: Customers can donate up to two pizzas per order, per day, and their order must include at least one pizza or calzone to qualify for the donation.

Birthday Club: The Birthday Club offers exclusive monthly perks to loyalty members. These perks will be communicated via SMS text message, and members must opt-in for SMS text messaging to receive them.

Accessing Deals and Specialty Items: To access deals, customers need to provide their loyalty phone number during the order process. All deals are subject to change without prior notice.

Loyalty Card and Recovery: The loyalty program does not utilize physical loyalty cards. Instead, it is managed through a server in Kay Jack’s Point of Sale Loyalty Software.

Modification and Termination: Kay Jack reserves the right to modify or terminate any part or the entire loyalty program at its discretion. This includes changes to individual points, earned rewards, and access to ordering.

Severability: If any part of the Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program terms and conditions is found to be invalid, unenforceable, or unlawful, the remaining provisions shall remain in full force and effect. The invalidity of any specific provision shall not affect the validity of the entire agreement.

Program Abuse: Kay Jack Pizza reserves the right to take appropriate action, including disqualification and termination of the Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program membership, if any member is found engaging in program abuse or fraudulent activities. Program abuse includes, but is not limited to, attempts to earn rewards through deceitful means, manipulation of the program’s rules, or any actions that undermine the integrity of the loyalty program. Decisions regarding program abuse shall be at the sole discretion of Kay Jack Pizza.

Dispute Resolution: Disputes related to the loyalty program will be handled on a case-by-case basis. If a dispute is not covered in these terms and conditions, the final decision lies with Kay Jack’s management team or owners.

Indemnification: By participating in the Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program, members agree to indemnify and hold Kay Jack Pizza, its affiliates, and representatives harmless from any claims, liabilities, or expenses arising from their participation. This includes any actions that may violate program terms, laws, or the rights of others. Kay Jack Pizza retains the right to control the defense of such claims. This clause survives program termination.

Opting-Out: Customers can opt-out of the loyalty program by calling Kay Jack Pizza, providing their loyalty phone number, and requesting to be removed from the program.

By participating in the Kay Jack Pizza Loyalty Program, members agree to abide by these terms and conditions. The program guidelines may be updated periodically, and any changes will be communicated to members via appropriate channels.

© copyright 2023 l Kay Jack Pizza LLC